In the stock market, value investors buy and hold
shares, waiting the moment when the price reflects the intrinsic value of the
company. If the company is operated well, then the share price increases. What
about speculators? They buy shares as they think they can sell it at a higher
price regardless of fundamentals. If there is only one speculator in the stock
market, he will pay for the risk. But if the market is crowded with
speculators, huge demand will push the price to the peak.
Adam Anderson (1787) describes the speculative
dynamics. A owns one hundred pounds in stock. B has confidence with A and buys
the stock. C notices that A and B have won profit, so he also comes in with
more money; and followed by D. More and more investors come in, which leads to
increase in price. However, such increase is caused by subsequent partnership.
What if no other investor comes in?
Immediately, the price
dives. We call such price reversal phenomenon, Bubble.
More specifically, if an asset experiences a sudden
dramatically price rise, the jump gives rise to optimism over earnings and
attracts new investors. As demand grows, the price keeps increasing. However,
once investors lose confidence in the asset, the price plunges. It is
emphasized that Bubble is a process from continuous price increase to collapse.
Expectation plays a key role in this process.
But what is exact
definition of Bubble?
Unfortunately, there is no consensus. Peter Garber, in
his book Famous First Bubbles, argues
that, a fuzzy word filled with import but
lacking any solid operational definition.
For example, Kindleberger proposes in his book, Manias, Crashes, and Panics (1996), “a
bubble is an upward price movement over an extended range that then implodes”.
Many scholars define bubble using price movement. In
economics, bubble is referred to a situation where ex post asset prices are
regarded as over-valued and not based on fundamentals.
Azariadis(1981)states that there are three
well-documented cases of speculative price movements, the Dutch tulip mania,
the South Sea bubble in England and the Mississippi bubble in France.
In the blog,
I would like to research the Mississippi bubble and divide the event into three
stages. In the first stage, we focus on how the bubble forms: a shock in
monetary system and growing optimism. In the second stage, the bubble is
inflated with credit expansion and surge in share price. In the last stage, negative
shock causes bubble collapse.
But
before these three stages, I would like to talk something about John Law and
his monetary theory in the next post. From my point of view, his story is pioneering!
No comments:
Post a Comment